Why are current laws insufficient?
The
U.S. Department of Agriculture licenses and inspects large-scale commercial
breeding operations to a certain extent and California law requires basic
humane standards. However, there are loopholes and a lack of enforcement
at both the federal and state level. There are no federal or state laws
that address the negative impact of large-scale breeding operations on
pet overpopulation. The Responsible Breeder Act of 2009 helps curb pet
overpopulation, prevents the inherent cruelty and poor welfare associated
with high-volume breeding, and will save the state money by limiting the
number of intact dogs and cats a seller can maintain.
Do puppy mills create a financial drain for government
and non-profit agencies?
Yes.
A criminal bust of a single puppy mill (for failing to comply with animal
welfare regulations) can result in significant taxpayer expense, as the
costs of shelter, food and vet care for animals can add up to tens of
thousands of dollars within weeks. For example, a puppy mill bust last
year where 249 animals were rescued in Buxton, Maine cost the state $440,000
in addition to approximately $70,000 raised by humane organizations. It’s
clear that puppy mills are a humane crisis as well as a financial one.
In 2007, nearly one million dogs and cats landed in California animal
shelters, of whom approximately half were euthanized (killed). At a cost
of nearly $250 million annually (or nearly $7.40 per capita), the economic
impact of pet overpopulation is significant.
How does AB 241 The Responsible Breeder Act of 2009 address
the problem of puppy mills?
Assemblyman
Nava’s bill addresses the problems puppy mills create by limiting
the number of intact cats or dogs a seller can maintain to 50. This bill
does not impact animal shelters, research facilities, pet stores, veterinarians,
groomers or boarding facilities. By limiting the number of animals who
can reproduce, this legislation will make enforcement of existing state
law possible and enable animal control to more effectively and efficiently
deal with complaints about dogs and cats living in squalid conditions
and receiving inadequate care. This legislation also addresses pet overpopulation
and the stress that large-scale breeders place on animal shelters and
our communities. Legislation limiting the number of dogs in puppy mills
was passed in 2008 in Louisiana and Virginia. Public concern about the
inhumane conditions in puppy mills is at an all-time high, due to recent
national news coverage and several large-scale cruelty investigations
and rescues. Outraged citizens are demanding an end to puppy mills.
|